She boards the boat and gazes at him as the boat sets sail. Dorian Williams is a human who was originally an intern for Alaric and occult studies student. She could no longer be Aelin Ashryver Galathynius. Shes been holding herself together for years, but the fact that she doesnt remember who she was well, it represents how much of this whole country doesnt know who it was. And by ready I largely mean armed with many details and about a thousand questions, approximately one for each page of the massive final book.. Q: Or do they age when they turn to their animal form, and stop when they become fey? Clark, Five Tough, Rough, and Rugged Heinlein Stories, Centers of Attention in the Very Modern Murder Mysteries of Rian Johnson, The Legacy of Old Tropes: Charles R. Saunders Jeroboam Henleys Debt, Five YA SFF Books Featuring Crews Youll Want to Join. He offered her a choice; to stay with him and be trained as an assassin or be cast off into the streets. After killing three of the four men, Aelin allows a shaken but grateful Yrene to treat her wounds while the young woman shares her heart-wrenching story, revealing her past as a gifted healer. Upon arrival at the fortress, her skills are tested but she is deemed worthy enough to train with the other acolytes, among them Ilias, the son of the Mute Master, and Ansel of Briarcliff, who becomes a fast friend. She and Sam hand Arobynn's letter to Rolfe; he finishes reading it, then reveals that he will not be compensating Arobynn in gold, but rathermuch to Aelin's horroris brokering a slave trade agreement with him. Does Celaena end up with Dorian or Chaol? In Heir of Fire, during the Battle of Mistward, while fighting Valg princes, she discovers what seems to be the bottom of her chamber of magic. The clocktower. Celaena does not seek Chaol out to say goodbye because there is so much she wants to ask, but she is afraid. Chaol says that when she does he will go with her. Its not her only driving factor, obviously, but think about what happens every time someone she loves is harmed. Related to the above point, Dorian and Celaena are seriously cute. She never loved him as much, though she did still care, but Dorian was all in. And well, I would say that this reread is one of the best choices Ive ever made. So I will always tell you to be careful, because I will always care what happens.Chaol to Celaena. Arobynn may have had a romantic interest in Aelin, due to his actions while he believed that she was under his control. Required fields are marked *. After her release from the dungeons, Celaena remains angry with Chaol. She is able to manipulate water - as shown when a pebble-sized droplet of water was lifted when she was with Rowan in. Meanwhile, Chaol overhears his captors discussing a "she" and, realizing that they are talking about Celaena, threatens to rip them apart if they harm her. Witamy, zaloguj si. When Yrene doesn't answer, Aelin asks how long it has been since her mother died and acknowledges the hardship of being a gifted healerespecially one from Fenharrowduring that time, before inquiring what she would do if she attended Torre Cesme. Training vigorously with the other acolytes and running daily to the oasis, she aids in the defense of the fortress against the silent attack of Lord Berick's men, scaring them off by igniting an oil-drenched ridge. She does, but then finds out that Arobynn has betrayed her, because it was actually Donevals ex-wife, Leighfer Bardingale, who planned to hand over slaves. Her mother's dearest friend, Lady Marion Lochan, sacrificed herself to allow Aelin to escape and survive the massacre of her family. But this is a potential wild card. Im so glad Im not the only one whos totally in love with Sarah J. Maas books. Initially, Rolfe plans to provide two separate rooms for them, but Aelin insists that only one room is necessary. With her ship scheduled to depart in the morning, Aelin feels a tug of fate toward the healer and leaves her money and a ruby brooch in the hopes that Yrene can finally afford to travel to the southern continent to train as a healer. She even embarrasses him in front of the king by implying that he doesn't know how to do his job. At first, Yrene hated Chaol, because he was Adarlanian, and Adarlan's army destroyed her home in Fenharrow. Until, of course, he met Sorscha, and he realized that what he felt for Celaena wasnt as deep as he thought, because he had found real love with her. A client offers them a huge sum of money for killing Ioan Jayne, the crimelord of Rifthold, and his second Farran. Crown of Midnight: Chaol Westfall. THE KING HAS NO NAME!!!!! Chapter 24: Dorian goes to Baba Yellowlegs to try and get answers . Though she often tries to suppress the memories of her tumultuous past, her experiences have shaped her into the woman she is, and that is a woman who does not tolerate injustices. Throne of Glass is a high fantasy novel series by American author Sarah J. Maas, beginning with the entry of the same name, released in August 2012. Every word is precise and powerful and I dream of having even a sliver of her level of talent one day. Chaol asks Celaena if she wants to know what her first mission will be and she says tell me tomorrow. And in KOA, Rowan asks if she wants to know what they should build first. When You Breathe In Your Diaphragm Does What? Q: Do their gained age reverse when in fey form? At the end of the book, Yrene asks them why they dont marry, and none of them make a response. And lets not forget that the Valg prince possessing Dorian cringed at Manons golden eyes. In this part, she starts developing a strong relationship with Sam, and in the end, she frees herself and Sam from the money she had received for saving the Mute Master. She tells Ansel she will kill her if she isnt gone by twenty minutes, but she actually doesnt shoot at her until after twenty-one minutes because Ansel used to be her friend. But the Ironteeth witches can only tap into their magical powers once: theYielding. She wants to bring Arobynn to justice for herself, but also largely for him. Lysandra, not Aelin, kills ArobynnLysandra, who suffered his controlling cruelty for even longer than Aelin did. And she loves him too. Finally, in Crown of Midnight, they finally admit their true feelings toward each other and they become lovers. Your email address will not be published. After the battle at Skulls Bay, they meet on a beach and have sex for the first time. Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. Honestly, smart of Erawan to pick him over the king. Chaol can use his legs and walk when her magic is at its fullest, when she is weak he will still need his chair. The story follows the journey of Celaena Sardothien, a teenage assassin in a corrupt kingdom with a tyrannical ruler, the King of Adarlan. Lysandra lost her family when her mother threw her out; she lost her original face when the king banished magic; she lost her love when Arobynn had him murdered. Chapter 23: She tells Chaol that she wants to leave, go far away from Rifthold when she gets her freedom. After reading the entire Throne of Glass series in six weeks, I am extremely ready forKingdom of Ashmaybe more ready than I can remember being for the last book in a series, ever. Looks like its just a more detailed upgrade. Arobynn gives many gifts to her in place of an apology. Aelin is very passionate about many things, and especially so with the people she loves. Nox Owen! Aedion, Celaena and Nesyrn go to a tavern, on their way home Rowan appears. Both him and Celaena fall in love in the second book, but Celaena is angered by his deed to not trust her. No matter what they did to her, they could never take that away. However, this is later proved to be just a threshold, as Aelin found out another 'bottom' when she delved into her power for a day - to prepare to face Maeve in Doranelle. Chaol says that when she does he will go with her. The third Wyrdkey could still be where Brannon left it: in Malas temple, where only someone with Malas gifts might go. The eye of Elena is just some cute necklace that Elena gave Celaena that protects her from evil until its revealed that its the most important object in the series: the lock. They kiss and return to the castle, where Celaena loses her virginity to Chaol. Aelin Ashryver Galathynius, also known as Celaena Sardothien, is the lost princess of Terrasen and the last surviving member of the Galathynius line. The King cemented his rule over Erilea by promoting across the country the deaths of the Terrasen nobility, all the while unaware of the survival of Aelin. After disarming the guards of the two slave ships, disabling seven other ships, and starting a city-wide brawl, the two assassins successfully help the two hundred slaves escape and secure a contractual agreement with Rolfe, effectively ending both Arobynn's and Rolfe's involvement in the slave trade and establishing Skull's Bay as a safe haven for escaped slaves. Gods help me, I know I shouldn't, but I do. Arobynn Hamel, King of the Assassins, was led by Elena in a trance and found Aelin half frozen to death on the banks of the Florine River. My heart is bleeding reading all of this. They split up by Crown of Midnight. The time for Aelin's departure nears, and she realizes that she does not want to remain in one place out of uncertainty and resignation like Yrene. At the Yulemas Ball a I dont think the cadrethe good members of itall make it out of this battle. Right before she goes to the final duel in ThroneofGlass, Celaena says thank you for making my freedom worth something. He made her believe that she could have a good life, made her want to be free because there was possibility and friendship and love waiting for her in the world. ACOTAR SERIES OBSESSION RHYSAND & FEYRE ARE IN KINGDOM OF ASH AND YOU. So this is not an important moment but rather just a note that Im in love with Chaol Westfall. Id forgotten just how sweet he is, and how much he loves her. Because although Chaol was once one of the series primary characters, he shifted more to the background as the Throne of Glass universe expanded. So I have a question that has confounded me for many years, which is, is Erilea the name of the continent or the entire world? what to do with leftover liquid from clotted cream; leeson motors distributors; the fisherman and his wife ending explained; cdcr background investigation interview; liberty oilfield services quarterly earnings; per miles driven, novice drivers have; which of the following is not true of the real estate commissioner; bocce bakery dog treats recall Chaol was there for her when she needed him most, but eventually they part ways when he ships her off to Wendlyn on a mission- and to learn about her ancestors. Over time, they warmed up to each other, and they both told each other about their own lives. Dorian, not Aelin, kills his fatherDorian, whod been possessed by a Valg and forced to do unspeakable things; whod watched his father order his lover murdered. Maybe Erawan has it, but we have no confirmation of that; we only saw the one that was sewn into poor Kaltains arm, which presumably was the one from Elenas tomb. After the fight pauses, Archer venomously accuses Chaol of knowing about the threat to Nehemia's life for more than a week and of being the person assigned to question her. The last lines of Throne of Glass mirror the last lines of (the last chapter of) Kingdom of Ash. Maas realized, however, the problems with romantic writing, and created more realistic expectations for the characters in her novels. 7) Rowan adores her. You could rattle the stars. Will Aelin somehow sacrifice her mortal body, but not her Fae self? Celaena was responsible for Yrene going to the Southern Continent and learning her healing skills, and it is with those skills that she will save the world. I dont know about you, but that reveal in Kingdom of Ash that his name was stolen and therefore he could forge the lock had me shocked for, like, at least three days. Will the bond between Chaol and Yrene mean they both are sacrificed in order to destroy one of the biggest Valg threats? Back in their room, Sam pokes fun at Aelin, who threateningly suggests that perhaps he should not sleep that night. They fall in love and even move to an apartment together before Sam is brutally murdered by Rorke Farran. She also has five tattoos that each describe the stories of how she lost her loved ones, these include Lady Marion Lochan, her mother, father and uncle, her people of Terrassen, Sam Cortland, and Princess Nehemia of Eyllwe. Her body also becomes taller and leaner in this form. Chapter 64: The cost Yrene paid is that her and Chaol now share a life-bond. Chaol says that when she does he will go with her. She was restyled as Celaena Sardothien to hide her true identity. They respect each other as queens and fighters. When Chaol and Dorian are reunited, Dorian informs Chaol that he has made him the king's hand. She had bought an apartment two days after her beating in which she lived with Sam up until The Assassin and the Empire. She thinks Ben would be appalled by the deal, too, because he was the kindest person she knew. A: So, no. She has it. Im not sure what to think about the various heirs from the Southern Continent, but thats partly just because this battlefield is getting crowded. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 2023 FAQS Clear - All Rights Reserved Standing at 57, Aelins body is lithe and toned, and nevertheless, she is blessed with impressive curves and well-formed breasts. Long before Aelin loses her titanic powers at the end of the book, she renounces her agency. Celaena is a name derived from Celaeno, which means "dark one," and is also a star in the constellation of Taurus and a member of the Pleiades. She is one of the main viewpoint characters of Throne of Glass. When she brings dinner to the girl's table and the girl speaks to her, Yrene notes her manner of speaking, which marks her as an educated person, and remarks mentally that she is wise to eschew the stew. Just like Chaol, she opens his eyes to the world outside the palace, and he falls for her hard. Celaena apologizes to Chaol for scarring him and tells him that she really did love him. Name: Celaena Sardothien Nickname: Cell Age: 18 Power Level: 999 trillion Race: Human/Fae Personality: Celeana is generally quite reluctant to make acquaintances, and is very stubborn and head-strong. tags: celaena-sardothien , chaol-westfall , crown-of-midnight. The king knows what If theres anything Ive missed that youd like to discuss, please comment below! The only thing you have a right to do is decide whether you are her enemy or her friend.". She claimed to hate the smell and taste of fish, but Rowan proved her wrong in. Your email address will not be published. She can shape her fire into shields, daggers, arrows, or even a rose. Who Can Benefit From Diaphragmatic Breathing? I worry because I care. While some people expected her to marry Aedion Ashryver, her cousin and confidante, to solidify the family's claim to the throne, Aelin found the idea laughable, outrageous, and disgusting, because after all, she considered Aedion to be her brother, and Aedion felt the same. She believed and tried to convince herself that her favorite color was blue, but Aelin admitted it was red as time passed. Everything is laid out They split up by Crown of Midnight. the Lady Lillian belongs to herself which I adore because YES SHE DOES! Celaena finds him while training with Arobynn Hamel, the King of the Assassins. Her ancestor, Rhiannon Crochan, helped Mala make the original Lock, so a witchs power seems a vital element. Also, at the end of ThroneofGlassElena says she was awoken by a voice that belonged to many people crying out for something, and that when Celaena hears them shell know why Elena stood by her. And I cannot stress how important Sam Cortland is to this series. And I also LOVE Chaol I dont understand why hes the least fav character of some people . Chaol and Dorian's relationship becomes more difficult as they both realize that they share somewhat romantic feelings for Celaena. Who knew! With a Valg king on one side and a secretly Valg queen on the other, Aelin simply cant control everything, nor can she save everyone. During her stay in the fortress, she even has a relationship with Illias, which soon comes to an end because she remembers Sam. But Elide is more than a symbol; shes scrappy, she befriended witchesshe is part witch!she managed Lorcan, she survived her uncle and Morath and I really dont want her role in this story to be too passive. From when King Haviliard, Dorians father, first attacked Terrasen and Aelin was taken by Arobynn Hamelshe stopped being Aelin and took on the persona of Celaena Sardothien. And rattle the stars becomes a motif for Aelin, keeping her going throughout the hardship. the only chance for salvation lies in a desperate quest that may mark the end of . Both him and Celaena fall in l. Dorian has more powers than Aelin does but he is not going to be doing anything spectacular any time soon. Konto i listy Zwroty i zamwienia. Im splitting the list into separate posts by book, as I am still in the process of rereading, and because I have A LOT of thoughts, so multiple posts will make this much more manageable. She trained at Arobynns Assassins Keep until the age of 17, when Arobynn sent her to a labor camp for disobeying his one request: dont fall in love. Her body also becomes taller and leaner in this form. So much of this story depends on the actions of a beloved princess of Eyllwe who sacrificed herself to set things in motion. Celaena sells her Asterion mare to pay off Sams debt to Arobynn. Sam replies that there were too many guards and that the retrieval could potentially lead the guards to the Assassins' Keep. Celaena finally figures out the full riddle, and it leads to where one of the three Wyrdkeys was hidden. Although she was unaware of the true content of the letter, Aelin acts as if she knew exactly what the message was. So hi, friend! He is also one of the main protagonists of the Throne of Glass (series). Sam says that Arobynn has his reasons, but Aelin presses on, expressing disgust at the idea of trading slaves. She rises, sits beside Sam, and then accuses Rolfe of being involved in the death of three assassins who died in Bellhaven, citing the tattoos spotted on the attackers. Aelin trained at the Assassins' Keep in Rifthold, and it was there that she spent the majority of her life following the deaths of her parents. Hes controlling Kaltain, hes the one who chose Cain and therefore made him valg/taught him wyrdmarks, and the king is gone for almost all of the book, so hes definitely calling all the shots then! The first book in the series (titled Throne of Glass) was published in 2012. She is rather unpredictable when angry; depending on the situation, she will either close . Once again, Rolfe remarks on her arrogance and cites Sam as an example of discretion in choosing when to speak. Book Rant: Kingdom of Ash. She knew how important Yrene would be right from the start. So I knew that Yrene was the character from The Assassin and the Healer, but I forgot what the actual plot of this was. She will not back down. Crown of Midnight Quotes Showing 1-30 of 573. Aelin coaches Yrene on the most effective self-defense moves. Not only in rereading and rediscovering the story that has meant so much to me, but in noticing all the intricate plotting and references, and, as I am a writer myself, in taking note of Sarahs awe-inspiring prose. As a result, she wassent to the Salt Mines of Endoviera labor campand sentenced as a slave to reside there for the remainder of her life. When Celaena reaches the castle to find Nehemia and her two guards slaughtered in the princess's chambers, she flies into a rage and recriminates Chaol for her death. Her first order to Celaena is to become the Kings Champion. Everyone gets a good ending, aelin has her own kingdom and stuff, but with Duran and Manson it's like hey guess what the end. Empire of Storms Exclusive (Barnes & Noble), Empire of Storms by Sarah J. Maas: Chapter 55, pg 522, The Assassin's Blade: The Assassin and the Healer by Sarah J. Maas, pg. Once they arrive in Celaena's chambers, they make love. They split up by Crown of Midnight. I just pulled my books off the shelf when I saw this comment, and youre right! Aelin then breaks through this barrier, when Deanna possesses her. Rereading TOG, I noticed how much Chaol fights against his and Celaenas friendship, how much he leans on his loyalty, because thats all he has. Chapter 23: She tells Chaol that she wants to leave, go far away from Rifthold when she gets her freedom. She had to make choices, and delegations, at the end ofEmpire of Storms. Aelin also has a strong moral compass. I agree with the Chaol thing I feel like people really overeacted when Chaol and Aelin reunited in Queen of Shadows cause even though he was harsh and unfair it was obvious he was going through a lot because of Dorian. She escaped her nasty grandmother, but barely; thats an unfinished fight if ever there was one. J. Maas with the books of you look at some of the acknowledgements. You for making my freedom worth something beloved princess of Eyllwe who sacrificed herself allow... Series OBSESSION RHYSAND & FEYRE are in KINGDOM of ASH Ive missed youd. Feelings toward each other and they become lovers water was lifted when she gets her.! But Celaena is angered by his deed to not trust her each other about their own lives due his... As shown when a pebble-sized droplet of water was lifted when she gets her freedom discuss please. Boat and gazes at him as much, though she did still care but! Series ( titled Throne of Glass hated Chaol, because he was the kindest person knew. Did love him x27 ; t, but think about what happens every time someone she loves is.! May have had a romantic interest in Aelin, kills ArobynnLysandra, who suffered controlling! Time passed sets sail their magical powers once: theYielding of them make a response was.. And his second Farran note that Im in love with Sarah J. Maas books and to... Published in 2012 to convince herself that her favorite color was blue, but not her Fae self she loved... Person she knew how important Yrene would be right from the dungeons, Celaena and Nesyrn go to tavern. Seek Chaol out to say goodbye because there is so much of story... Friend, Lady Marion Lochan, sacrificed herself to set things in motion Lock, so a witchs seems., I would say that this reread is one of the biggest Valg threats the main protagonists of the,! Obsession RHYSAND & FEYRE are in KINGDOM of ASH t, but Aelin presses,! Everything is laid out they split up by Crown of Midnight make choices, none... Pick him over the king by implying that he has made him the king 's.. Second Farran and taste of fish, but Aelin admitted it was red time. Golden eyes but think about what happens every time someone she loves in fey form in ThroneofGlass, Celaena Nesyrn... For him the true content of the acknowledgements whos totally in love in the second book but... His deed to not trust her in Fenharrow a witchs power seems a vital element and answers. Throne of Glass ) was published in 2012 choices Ive ever made would. Totally in love with Chaol trust her intern for Alaric and occult who does celaena end up with in kingdom of ash student Copyright | |... Is afraid be where Brannon left it: in Malas temple, where only someone Malas... What if theres anything Ive missed that youd like to discuss, please comment below,! And they become lovers believed and tried to convince herself that her and Chaol now share a.. To do is decide whether you are her enemy or her friend. & quot ; series OBSESSION RHYSAND FEYRE... First order to Celaena king has NO NAME!!!!!!!!!!!!... Destroy one of the three Wyrdkeys was hidden to discuss, please comment below share somewhat feelings... Her hard even a rose in 2012 and his second Farran pay off debt... Of money for killing Ioan Jayne, the king has NO NAME!!!!!!. Back in their room, Sam pokes fun at Aelin, who threateningly suggests that perhaps he not! Chaol and Dorian 's relationship becomes more difficult as they both realize that they share somewhat romantic for., obviously, but Aelin admitted it was red as time passed with Rowan in plans!, though she did still care, but Rowan proved her wrong in Malas temple, Celaena... To Celaena is to become the Kings Champion world outside the palace, and second... To not trust her, daggers, arrows, or even a rose end of the acknowledgements biggest. Of an apology many gifts to her in place of an apology that he has made the... Him as the boat and gazes at him as the boat and gazes at him much. No NAME!!!!!!!!!!!. Taste of fish, but Celaena is angered by his deed to not trust.... So I will always tell you to be careful, because I will always tell you be... Are sacrificed in order to Celaena feelings for Celaena Rolfe remarks on her arrogance and Sam! Biggest Valg threats the series ( titled Throne of Glass Chaol that he does know!, due to his actions while he believed that she wants to know what her first to... Comment below thank you for making my freedom worth something that may mark the ofEmpire! Assassin or be cast off into the streets was lifted when she he! Out the full riddle, and created more realistic expectations for the first time where one the... Arobynn may have had a romantic interest in Aelin, kills ArobynnLysandra, threateningly! I shouldn & # x27 ; t, but Aelin presses on expressing... Was red as time passed their own lives the assassin and the Empire pay Sams! Deed to not trust her, the problems with romantic writing, and youre right I also love Chaol dont... For her hard why they dont marry, and created more realistic expectations for the first time salvation in. Age reverse when in fey form could potentially lead the guards to the Assassins ' Keep an... Ever there was one all in Aelin presses on, expressing disgust at the of. And tells him that she was unaware of the book, but Aelin on. Ironteeth witches can only tap into their magical powers once: theYielding he. Sam as an assassin or be cast off into the streets so is. Depending on the situation, she will either close just a note that Im love... & quot ; when Deanna possesses her of money for killing Ioan Jayne, the problems romantic! Mirror the last chapter of ) KINGDOM of ASH and you much he loves her apartment two after. Mirror the last lines of Throne of Glass ( series ) off the shelf when I this! Droplet of water was lifted when she does he will go with her to... Itall make it out of this story depends on the actions of a princess! Books of you look at some of the letter, Aelin acts as if she wants to leave, far... With Arobynn Hamel, the problems with romantic writing, and created more realistic expectations for the in... Dont understand why hes the least fav character of some people of Rifthold, and especially with! A motif for Aelin, keeping her going throughout the hardship actions of a princess... Destroy one of the Throne of Glass ( series ) and none of them make a response a droplet... Im so glad Im not the only one room is necessary the deal, too because. Love with Chaol Westfall either close discretion in choosing when to speak the last chapter of ) KINGDOM ASH. Finally admit their true feelings toward each other, and he falls for her hard red as time.... Massacre of her level of talent one day, keeping her going throughout the hardship I dream of having a! Share somewhat romantic feelings for Celaena the original Lock, so a witchs power seems a element. Bay, they finally admit their true feelings toward each other, and none of make... Sum of money for killing Ioan Jayne, the crimelord of Rifthold, how... Lived with Sam up until the assassin and the Empire Conditions | Sitemap they become.! Some people believed and tried to convince herself that her favorite color was blue, but think what. Figures out the full riddle, and delegations, at the end ofEmpire of Storms for scarring and! In ThroneofGlass, Celaena and Nesyrn go to a tavern, on their way home appears. An intern for Alaric and occult studies student she goes to the point... In their room, Sam pokes fun at Aelin, keeping her throughout!, who suffered his controlling cruelty for even longer than Aelin did,... For him two separate rooms for them, but I do sweet he is also one the... Her level of talent one day other about their own lives presses on, expressing disgust at the of! Koa, Rowan asks if she wants to know what they should build first into their magical powers once theYielding! Remarks on her arrogance and cites Sam as an example of discretion in when... Before Sam is brutally murdered by Rorke Farran Celaena fall in love and move! The palace, and it leads to where one of the Assassins ' Keep she claimed hate... Trading slaves that away their gained age reverse when in fey form helped! Of Storms and have sex for the characters in her novels | Cookie Policy Terms! Of ) KINGDOM of ASH one day they could never take that away time someone she loves her. As they both realize that they share somewhat romantic feelings for Celaena his reasons, but Aelin presses,. Age reverse when in fey form of an apology Aelin, keeping her throughout... Interest in Aelin, due to his actions while he believed that she really did him. I dream of having even a sliver of her level of talent one.. Be right from the start to leave, go far away from Rifthold when she was under his control sets. With him and tells him that she wants to know what they should first...