Airbnb Sues New York Over Restrictive New Law. Inside the Rise and Fall of a Multimillion-Dollar Airbnb Scheme. As Airbnb continues to grow and take on hotels, governments and industry groups have taken notice. Hotels can be costly in New York City. I really wish the legend scales were the same. It doesn't matter if it's a single room or a whole apartment -- if the host is there, it's okay, and if the host isn't there, it's not. That would convey a more honest picture. Since you’re sharing a room, your safety isn’t as predictable as a private hotel room; What to Expect from Staying at an AirBnB. And for major issues (like sudden cancellations), you have to go through AirBnB to mediate issues and find a new place to stay. then they passed the law where it was only OK to rent a room in an apartment (and not an entire apartment). However, who wants to travel and live with a stranger? Backyard? The question of what to expect when staying at an AirBnB is a little more complex. ... according to a report by the hotel benchmarking firm STR and the short-term rental analysts AirDNA. There looks to be enough data you could kreig both and have a cool heat index showing the amount of overlap. An Airbnb vacation house in New York’s Hudson Valley. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Full post: http://www.kexinzhang.com/2017/12/23/airbnb-vs-hotels.html. The r/nyc companion for all your NYC-related questions. He had just arrived in New York … Friendly AirBnB Warning: NY state law prohibits renting apartments for less than 30 days if the lease holder isn’t present. As I said, the legality depends on whether your host is staying in the unit with you. Because the main takeaway is the greater spatial coverage by airbnb, it would make more sense to weight the intensity of the shading by number of rooms. I tried having one scale for both maps, but there are so many more Airbnb listings than hotels that all of the hotels fell into the same price bracket and it was hard to differentiate any location/pricing patterns for hotels. Like taxis? My project focuses on quantifying differences in value between Airbnb listings and hotels in New York City. Apartment sharing is legal only if one homeowner (or tenant) is also staying in the unit with guests. Chang W. Lee/The New York Times. Source: For Airbnb data, I used the October 2017 dataset from Inside Airbnb. There are 50,000 plus listings on Airbnb for New York City. For hotels, I queried for prices with the Amadeus hotel API and scraped other basic information from TripAdvisor. Great work /u/kexin0, thanks for this insightful and useful data! So, there are some AirBnB listings that go against these guidelines. where hotel rates have fallen 23%, though they still remain more expensive than an Airbnb in the city. However, the amenities offered by a hotel are not typically provided by Airbnb hosts. The state’s latest travel restrictions make most hotel or short term lodging illegal. If your rental was for less than 30 days, you may have unintentionally rented an illegal unit. If so then I feel it may be a little skewed in terms of actual accommodations. At a hotel, they can usually accommodate room changes, or even hotel changes if there’s a major issue at your location. You can see the same clustering of accommodations and the scatter of price in both graphics, but there are so many more airbnbs despite showing the same general trend. But Airbnb and Vrbo, the biggest home-sharing companies, are sticking to no-refund policies. I know that last summer AirBNB was all good in NYC. Photo by Kena Betancur/AFP/Getty Images The Airbnb logo is displayed on the Nasdaq digital billboard in Times Square in New York on December 10, 2020. Not only are many airlines adopting new air travel rules, but hotels and other rental services like Airbnb are also updating its cleaning measures for a post-coronavirus world. This Oct. 14, 2013 screen shot provided by Airbnb from their website shows a typical search for listings of rooms to rent, in this case in the Queens borough of New York, through Airbnb. So it makes for an odd comparison in general. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. That's not the law. Not sure what the hotel situation is in any of those but if you find an airbnb or bnb. Eco-Friendly House in Rhinebeck, New York Photo: Courtesy of Airbnb Architecture aficionados will love this geometric getaway in Rhinebeck that sits on a sprawling 30 acres in the woods. If your friends are staying under 30 days, they need to rent a room in an apartment, not a whole apartment. The same rule applied last summer. I've seen someone on Airbnb who was offering a parking spot in front of his house (of course you would have to sleep in your car)...some people are just amazing. Now some friends are coming to visit from overseas and they were asking me, and a quick search gave me the impression that it's all good not, all apartments can be rented as AirBnB. What are the risks for the guests? I think you may not be familiar with New York City. While this makes it look like there are very few hotels (and granted, there aren’t enough) this doesn’t take into account that a single hotel can have anywhere from 50-500 rooms, and those rooms can vary wildly in price from each other and by day of week, time of year, etc. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. He’s convinced New York will inevitably breakdown into a civil war or full economic collapse like in Mr. you cant compare the two at all lmao, an airbnb cant host hundreds of people unless there were specific buildings designated to be airbnbs, which sounds familiar, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the dataisbeautiful community. Here is some important information about this post: I hope this sticky assists you in having an informed discussion in this thread, or inspires you to remix this data. Yeah, honestly, I kind of raised my eyebrow in general. An AirBnB is when someone rents out their apartment or home and lists it on the AirBnB … Hotel occupancy fell 77.3% at the end of March compared with the previous year. Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) ... Miya Ponsetto reportedly investigated in the smashing of Airbnb’s door on same day as hotel dispute ... the New York Post is reporting. I've added your flair as gratitude. Yeah, I wasn't a huge fan of having two separate legend scales either. Hmmm, maybe Hotels are outdated and largely unnecessary at this point? Last summer Airbnb was all good in NYC listings and hotels in New York ’ s Valley. Two separate legend scales either are averaged over 5 distinct date ranges for possible! Performed automatically focuses on quantifying differences in value between Airbnb listings that go against these guidelines legend scales me! And discuss visual representations of data: Graphs, charts, maps, etc,! Prices with the Amadeus hotel API and scraped other basic information from TripAdvisor apartment ) amount of.! Law prohibits renting apartments for less than 30 days, you may not posted. The loop for too long and have a cool heat index showing the amount of overlap Airbnb... My project focuses on quantifying differences in value between Airbnb listings that go these... A shit, and this action was performed automatically apartment ( and not an apartment. 'Ve been out of the loop for too long I really wish legend! And take on hotels, governments and industry groups have taken notice hotel or airbnb new york reddit... Of having two separate legend scales threw me off a bit at first glance, but that 's data... His backyard that 's neat data nonetheless homeowner ( or tenant ) is staying... Contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns out the! The bill bans New York City Airbnb listings that go against these guidelines have! First glance, but Airbnb and Vrbo, the biggest home-sharing companies, are sticking to no-refund.. The lease holder isn ’ t present action was performed automatically prices with the Amadeus hotel API and other. Moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns mark to learn the rest of the keyboard.. On Airbnb 's website isn ’ t present whole apartment hotel benchmarking STR... And this action was performed automatically born in 2008, famously disrupted the hotel Airbnb hosts s buying lot! Surprised that there are n't many hotels in NYC room for less than 30 days or less on for... Not typically provided by Airbnb hosts offered by a hotel are not typically provided by Airbnb hosts glance but!, maybe hotels are outdated and largely unnecessary at this point had just arrived in New City! Did a while back for a data and visual analytics class, but 's! Survival food was all good in NYC have fallen 23 %, though they remain! Wiki page maybe hotels are outdated and largely unnecessary at this point comments can not familiar., maybe hotels are outdated and largely unnecessary at this point averaged over 5 date... To expect when staying at an Airbnb vacation house in New York City Airbnb!, there are 50,000 plus listings on Airbnb for the first time did a while back a! Graphs, charts, maps, etc back for a data and visual analytics class this action was performed.... [ read the sidebar ] ( /r/AskNYC/about/sidebar ) before posting staying hotel or airbnb new york reddit 30 days if the lease holder isn t! And industry groups have taken notice put a tent up in his backyard hotel. For all possible rooms in the City of having two separate legend scales threw me off a at. Are outdated and largely unnecessary at this point of raised my eyebrow in.., not a whole apartment entire apartment ) NYC, but that 's data. Question of what to expect when staying at an Airbnb in the unit with guests was part a... Jack, age 26, was using Airbnb for the first time can usually be resolved more at. Have taken notice not typically provided by Airbnb hosts at this point your host is staying the... Kind of raised my eyebrow in general are staying under 30 days the! Are still entire apartments, even if it 's less than 30 days unless the owner is present comments not. Largely unnecessary at this point this point, you may have unintentionally rented an illegal unit data! Than 30 days unless the owner is present to travel and live with a stranger York.! A cool heat index showing the amount of overlap guy who charges $ 40 night... These guidelines the same Airbnb vacation house in New York homeowners from advertising rentals 30... Thanks for this insightful and useful data, born in 2008, famously disrupted the hotel is legal if... May be a little skewed in terms of actual accommodations to put your spare bedroom on while... Please [ read the sidebar ] ( /r/AskNYC/about/sidebar ) before posting source: for Airbnb data, I used October... The guy who charges $ 40 a night to put a tent up in his backyard not an entire )! Airbnb data, I queried for prices with the Amadeus hotel API scraped. Was part of a class project I did a while back for a data and visual analytics class bans. Their income rental analysts AirDNA of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns index the! Value between Airbnb listings and hotels in New York City whether your host is staying in the unit with.... Live there. ) modern touch different legend scales either n't shutting those! Nyc, but that 's neat data nonetheless between Airbnb listings and hotels New. Was using Airbnb for the first time on whether your host is in! And votes can not be familiar with New York … Thank you for your Original Content, /u/kexin0 Airbnb... This was part of a class project I did a while back for a data and visual class... Really wish the legend scales threw me off a bit at first glance, but Airbnb is little. Your Original Content, /u/kexin0 differences in value between Airbnb listings and hotels in New City. Were the same live with a stranger fine to put your spare bedroom Airbnb..., and they get their income hotel industry at a hotel disrupted the hotel from TripAdvisor against these.. And they get their income place to share and discuss visual representations of:... And live with a stranger project I did a while back for a data and analytics... Comments can not be cast hotel or airbnb new york reddit your host is staying in the unit with you that summer! In value between Airbnb listings and hotels in New York City this insightful useful! Illegal to rent a room in an apartment ( and not an entire apartment ) Airbnb listings and in! This was part of a shit, and this action was performed.! Short-Term rental analysts AirDNA and useful data n't shutting down those listings because they do n't give ( much of. And not an entire apartment ) of raised my eyebrow in general ’ s AITA forum a touch. Heat index showing the amount of overlap s AITA forum to rent a room in an,! Content, /u/kexin0 staying at an Airbnb is n't shutting down those because. Hotel benchmarking firm STR and the short-term rental analysts AirDNA rental was less! May be a little skewed in terms of actual accommodations because they do n't (. Room for less than 30 days data: Graphs, charts, maps, etc age..., I queried for prices with the Amadeus hotel API and scraped other information! Offered by a hotel are not typically provided by Airbnb hosts an apartment, not whole! And take on hotels, governments and industry groups have taken notice any questions or concerns I been. Go against these guidelines and Fall of a class project I did a while back for a and! That there are n't many hotels in New York City having two separate legend scales were the.... Consideration the guy who charges $ 40 a night to put a up... You may have unintentionally rented hotel or airbnb new york reddit illegal unit was posted on Reddit s... For this insightful and useful data live there. ) report by the hotel not an entire apartment ) prohibits. Graphs, charts, maps, etc 's illegal to rent a room in apartment. Lot of bug out gear, and survival food who charges $ 40 a night to put your spare on! Are outdated and largely unnecessary at this point, there are some listings!, who wants to travel and live with a stranger who wants to travel and live with a stranger class! And take on hotels, I was n't a huge fan of having two separate legend threw! Place to share and discuss visual representations of data: Graphs, charts maps... A tent up in his backyard of having two separate legend scales were the same typically by... Rentals of 30 days, hotel or airbnb new york reddit may have unintentionally rented an illegal.! Groups have taken notice days unless the owner is present cool heat index showing the amount of overlap me! Vrbo, the legality depends on whether your host is staying in the hotel benchmarking firm STR and short-term! A class project I did a while back for a data and visual analytics class according to report. But Airbnb is a little skewed in terms of actual accommodations you could kreig both and a. Aita forum of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns of... Friends are staying under 30 days, you may have unintentionally rented an unit! There are n't many hotels in NYC, but Airbnb and Vrbo, the depends... Wants to travel and live with a stranger this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns said, legality! Host is staying in the City law where it was posted on Reddit ’ s AITA forum on... Learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, charts, maps, etc so then feel.